People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Sal’s is a real family style pizza. Best pizza around either in a slice or whole. Their pasta is fabulous also. They also have wedges, salads, and a selection of appetizers. Kids love it as well as adults. Great location where you can eat quick in order to catch a show at the Emelin or a movie or to make the train. ”
“ Rumors of their Sicilian have spread, and it didn’t disappoint ”
“ The best sicilian, but the round pizza is even better. Good quality. Somewhat thin crust (not the thinnest), good sauce, good cheese. Salad pizza is pretty unique and good. Small note: im not a fan of their buffalo slice. ”
“ Great pizzeria vibe and slices coming from Sal's! Buffalo slice was perfectly spicy and had no blue cheese or red sauce what so ever, the way a buffalo slice should be! Sicilian crust had a great crunch, ratio of cheese to sauce on the Sicilian is a cheese lovers dream! All in all a great experience this weekend with the family! Sicilian pie is so big it barely fits in the box! ”
“ I love Sal’s - I’ve visited a few times since moving to the area. The staff are lovely and the pizza is great - my favorite is the buffalo chicken - highly recommend! Old school business taking cash only - a great local spot! ”
“ Everything about Sal’s Pizza is just so good, even though my chicken Parm slice came with cheese that wasn’t fully melted. The fact that they used regular grilled chicken pieces instead of fried chicken cutlets was a pleasant surprise, and the flavor was ridiculously incredible. I didn’t even get a chance to snap a photo before devouring it, lol. Just a heads-up—there’s no Verizon cell service in the back, and I couldn’t figure out the Wi-Fi, so be aware you’re in a dead zone. But despite that, it’s definitely worth five stars. Sal’s is iconic! ”
“ Ohhh mannn! I needed a quick slice before going to the movies and this place did not disappoint! Best part of this area is that there are two restaurants across the street from one another that serve pizza. This one looked like I could get a quick slice. I was wrong! I had to wait on line to order two regular slices. My theory is if a pizzeria has a line it must be good! It def was! So good that I burned my top gums also cause I was in a rush. I loved the taste to the slice and the customer service was great. Everyone is on point and they work like a team! I can’t wait to go back there and order different dishes and not rush while eating. Can’t wait to enjoy their slices and pepperoni pinwheels! ”
“ You only go there for one reason...the pizza. I had the chicken and veggie slice...excellent. Their famed Sicilian is also always good. ”
Menu
Plain
1 Topping
2 Toppings
3 Toppings
Special
About
Sal's Pizza Mamaroneck
Welcome to Sal's Pizza Mamaroneck, the perfect culinary spot nestled at 316 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY. Known for its inviting family-friendly atmosphere, Sal’s has quickly risen as a go-to destination not just for locals but for pizza lovers across the region. Whether you’re dropping by for a quick slice before catching a show at the Emelin Theatre or settling in for a family meal, Sal’s provides a delightful experience that keeps customers coming back.
Renowned for its authentic and mouth-watering fare, Sal's specializes in traditional pizza that caters to all cravings. Their Sicilian pizza, praised affectionately by many, showcases a perfect balance of cheese and sauce that leaves aficionados raving. As resident customer Chris M noted, the rumors surrounding its Sicilian slice are well-deserved, an experience that truly lives up to the hype.
However, don’t overlook the round pizza, which Jesse Zolna claimed is even better, embodying a thin yet satisfying crust topped with quality ingredients—a testament to Sal's commitment to excellence. Each bite delivers a significant crunch paired with rich flavors, making it a quintessential choice for any pizza enthusiast. And for those who crave a unique twist, the salad pizza adds an innovative flair that you won’t find many other places.
Sal’s menu isn’t limited to just pizza. The family-style pasta dishes provide a fabulous complement to the menu, and many customers rave about the delectable wedges and fresh salads. There’s something for everyone, making it a hit among both children and adults alike. Grainne Ni Hodhrain’s enthusiasm for the buffalo chicken pizza speaks volumes about the variety Sal's offers—it's a must-try for the adventurous eater.
The ambiance at Sal’s is warm and inviting, enhancing the dining experience. Patrons often highlight the restaurant's old-school charm, especially since it operates as a cash-only establishment—a nostalgic nod to simpler times. With an easy-going vibe and friendly staff who are eager to ensure each visit is enjoyable, Sal's Pizza Mamaroneck is not just a place to eat, but a beloved local hangout.
In conclusion, if you're in the Mamaroneck area, make your way to Sal's Pizza Mamaroneck. Indulge in slices that make your taste buds dance and enjoy a homely atmosphere that warms your heart. You can reach them at +1 914-381-2022 for any inquiries. Your next pizza experience awaits!
Book a table